The key word for me is discernment… The further you are down the bell curve, the more intentionality, the more extreme measures are needed.
—Andy Sytsma
Summary of This Episode
Andy Sytsma has been a guest on this show a few times, and he comes back this week from Salt Lake City, where he pastors Life in Christ CRC. He and his wife moved to Utah just over three years ago after fourteen years at New Life CRC in Houston. They weren't looking to leave Texas. Four different pastors told him about the church in Salt Lake before he ever looked at it, and when he asked what brought him there, his answer was two words: God's call.
Alongside the pastorate he serves part-time with Resonate Global Mission as a local mission leader for the U.S. West, which he's done since 2017. It's one day a week, eight hours, and he describes it as catalytic and supportive at the same time. Resonate works in three areas—church planting, local mission, and global missions—and his is church planting: assessments, coaching, connecting planters to parent churches, finances, credentialing, immigration help. Resonate has a name for the part of it he says he's done his whole life, borrowed from Acts: Barnabas advocate. Ethnic diaspora pastors show up with real gifts and no map of the system, and somebody has to sit down and answer how a parent church works and how a man gets credentialed.
That work runs straight into the 10-Year Church Planting Plan, which Synod 2025 mandated after Scott Vander Ploeg asked for it from the floor. Tim Sheridan led it, seven collaborative teams produced about eighty pages, and Andy sat on two of them. He walks through the order the plan is built in, and the order is the argument: rooted in the gospel, motivated by prayer, then a culture of discipleship and reproducing disciples and raising up leaders—and only then do you start talking about church plants. On the other end of the life cycle sit the churches that close, and the legacy fund that lets a closing congregation reinvest in the work. Most of them have never heard of it.
Willy asks the question: what does it actually look like for a church to close well? Andy doesn't soften it. A closing is a death, there's real mourning in it, and you don't take it lightly. His one-word answer for how you get there is discernment, and he spends the next twenty minutes making that word practical. Revitalization is for a church halfway down the bell curve—struggling, plateaued, needing more than a refreshed vision, but not needing to die. Rebirth is closing the church, letting it die, and using the building and some of the same people to plant something new in the same place. Jason names the thing most councils don't know: they think the options are walk away or turn it around, and the third one is sitting right there.
He knows that third one from the inside. The church he came to in Paterson had seventy or eighty people when it discerned it ought to die—not because it was small, but because of what its own leaders saw spiritually. It was down to fifty or sixty when it closed, and forty-five of those stayed for the rebirth. Andy's counsel on the process is to get a multitude of counselors around the table, make sure the council is on board, and refuse to rush. In Houston, Peace Community Church decided it was near the end of its life cycle and joined one of the church plants instead of shutting down—two congregations, English and Spanish, worshiping together. They sold their building. He says he didn't expect that outcome and it's turned out beautifully.
The last stretch is his own story. He grew up a missionary kid in Japan, where his father and grandfather served, watching CRC and OPC missionaries work side by side with Reformed Church of Japan evangelists to start churches. The RCJ is about 150 congregations now and the CRC helped start roughly half of them since the war. His father just published a book about it. Andy felt the call to North America instead, and Seattle taught him what that meant—his wife explaining to a coworker that they'd come to start a church for people who'd given up on church but not on God, and the man asking her what the hell for. Paterson taught him that God raises dead things to life, with Ezekiel 37 as the text. Texas taught him what it looks like to daughter churches: twenty CRCs planted in fourteen years, his church the parent for half of them.
God has done a great deal of this already, in places most of us never looked. Praise God for it.
Next Sunday: the second half of our conversation with Andy Sytsma, on how an ordinary church plants a church.
Your council may be sitting on a decision it thinks has two options. What would it take to put the third one on the table? Reply to this email or leave a comment. We read them.

