“People think they have to be a certain size or have a certain amount of money. You don't have to be this huge church… Don't despise small things, small beginnings” —Andy Sytsma
Summary of This Episode
Jason starts this half with a piece of work Classis Wisconsin actually did: going back through its own church plants, the ones that lasted and the ones that didn't, and asking why. The conclusion was that a healthy mother church is almost essential to a healthy church plant. Andy sat on the partnerships team for the 10-Year Church Planting Plan, which spent its time on the same question, so he has an answer ready.
It begins with a warning. Don't smother the planter. Don't stack up hoops for him to jump through. Empower him, be gracious, give him room to try things—and then support him, because he needs a great deal of it. What that looked like in Houston was a partnership team around each planter: the planter himself, Andy, an elder or a member from the parent church, a leader or two from the new church, sometimes a classis leader. Five or six people functioning as an embryonic council. They met regularly and took minutes, and those minutes went onto the agenda of Andy's own council, so the mother church could see the finances and the state of the work. Once a year they took the credentialing language at face value and had the planter in the room: how are you, how's your family, how's your doctrine. Andy's phrase for the whole arrangement is low control, high accountability, and it's the best three words in the episode.
He's equally plain about what his church did badly. Two church plants worshiped in their building, which most CRCs never consider as the asset it is. But the congregation was never really on board with the planting work—it was Andy, the treasurer, and a handful of leaders. They tried to send families to a plant thirty minutes away and didn't have the mass for it. Jason puts the same failure the other way around, from Wisconsin: the plants that died were the ones where the mother church blessed and released and then disappeared. Both of them land on the church order as the fix. Unorganized status isn't a filing category; it's a council with real authority standing over a new church as support and oversight, and Andy's version is that you can't let a plant be an island disconnected from classis.
Somebody walked up to Jason at Synod and asked which church Bethel is going to plant, since it's the second largest in Classis Wisconsin. So what does a church need in place first? Andy goes to Acts 13, where it was in worship and prayer and fasting that the church at Antioch heard the Spirit send out Paul and Barnabas—not a grandmaster plan. Prayer, then discipleship, then leader development, and don't rush any of it. At Synod this summer half the delegates were upstairs talking about Thrive and existing churches while half were downstairs on the plan, and the downstairs conversation opened not with go plant a church but with how many of you have been discipled and how many of you are making disciples.
Then the part Andy came to say. The average CRC assumes this work belongs to big churches with money, and he refuses it. Diego and Camila came out of Argentina, planted in Reynosa on the Texas border with no salary and no connection to the CRC, washed dishes in a restaurant to pay for it, grew that church to two hundred, handed it off, and came to Houston. They planted again, daughtered another church, and are now starting one in Italy. Stephenville CRC began with Dutch farmers praying in an upper room, and eventually called a pastor and started a Christian school. Jason tells his own: a seventy-member congregation with money sitting in the bank, a council that looked at him like he was nuts when he proposed planting, and not one of them able to say why not. He kept telling them God hadn't given them that money to store up in barns.
The last stretch is the confessions, and Jason says outright that this is his way of getting the ecclesiology work in through the side door after Synod rejected the study committee. He asks what it takes to plant a church that's confessionally Reformed. Andy's answer is that evangelism has to be the motive—you're not gathering up Reformed people who already exist—and that you tell people what you believe from the first week. In Paterson they asked whether Reformed meant reform school. 222Disciple is built on the catechism. Office bearer training ought to produce elders who know what's in the confessions and are glad about it, not men who sign the form of subscription and hope. Jason uses Heidelberg Question 1 as an evangelistic question, because asking a man where he looks for comfort in life and in death reaches anybody. Willy says the young people he talks to name the liturgy before the doctrine. Andy ends with Fernando Rosario, who took the plan to every pastor and every council in Classis Central California in person, because this isn't coming top down from Grand Rapids.
Diego and Camila washed dishes to pay for a church. Dutch farmers in Stephenville started with nothing but an upper room and prayer. God built both.
Next Sunday: Ted Powers of the PCA’s Midwest Alliance.
Andy says prayer together is the thing we are least serious about. When did your council last pray together about anything other than a budget? Reply to this email or leave a comment. We read them.

